Several regional churches have planted video-venue campuses from Ashburn to Leesburg, allowing rapid growth across the county. Critics argue that a campus where the sermon arrives on a screen lacks genuine pastoral presence, while supporters say the unified teaching and shared mission outweigh any downsides.
Join the debate to comment
Reading is free. Members pay to post — that's why it stays clean.
Add your commentI want to push back on my fellow Ashburn locals who are defending this model so enthusiastically. Ask yourself honestly: when is the last time the lead pastor — the one on the screen — knew your name? Visited your home? Sat with you in grief? The campus can have wonderful community and I don't deny that. But the man being called "our pastor" by five congregations is no one's pastor in the way the New Testament means it. He's a teacher. A gifted one, maybe. But we should stop conflating the two because it lets everybody off the hook for the hard, slow, unglamorous work of actual pastoral care.
Born and raised in Ashburn, attended one of these multi-site churches for six years, and I'll tell you exactly what it is: it's a franchise. A spiritual Chick-fil-A. Same menu everywhere, local staff just keeps the fries warm. I don't say that to be entirely cruel — the teaching is often excellent — but let's not pretend the campus pastor in Leesburg has anything close to the authority or relationship with the flock that a real shepherd has. When my father was in the hospital, it was a volunteer small group leader who showed up, not anyone who could be called my pastor in any meaningful sense.
Fun fact for the people clutching their pearls: Charles Spurgeon's sermons were printed in newspapers every week and read aloud in churches across England that Spurgeon never visited. Was that not "real" preaching? The medium changes, the Word doesn't. Calm down.
I actually asked our campus pastor point blank last year whether he could perform my wedding and he had to check with the main campus about the "brand standards" for ceremonies. BRAND STANDARDS. For a wedding. In a church. That was the moment I realized this thing we were calling a church was actually a very well-produced religious product.
ok but can we talk about how Loudoun County grew by like 40,000 people in a decade?? if the traditional one-building model was so great at reaching people maybe we wouldnt need this conversation. my neighbor came to faith at a video venue campus and she's the most on-fire christian i know. sorry but results matter
The Apostle Paul wrote letters to churches he hadn't visited in years and those letters are literally Scripture. Communication across distance doesn't invalidate spiritual authority or community. I think people romanticize the idea of a pastor who knows everyone's name when statistically most megachurch attenders don't have that relationship ANYWAY even under one roof.
Theologically speaking, the New Testament defines a church by Word, sacrament, and discipline administered to a gathered people. Key word: gathered. One screen connecting five locations does not constitute one gathering any more than watching the Super Bowl at five different houses constitutes one party. These are five churches. Just own it and structure your polity accordingly.
Somebody correct me if Im wrong but I believe John Calvin himself argued that church unity is primarily doctrinal not geographical so technically five campuses with identical confessional commitments would be MORE unified than five independent Baptist churches three miles apart who cant agree on anything. checkmate i guess??
Moved here from rural Tennessee two years ago and I will never stop being weirded out by watching a guy preach on a 12-foot screen while a campus pastor stands off to the side like a very tall PowerPoint clicker. No shade to anyone who loves it. It's just not for me and I don't think that's just preference — I think presence is theologically significant in ways we're only starting to reckon with.
As someone who drives past three of these campuses on my Route 7 commute every morning, I'll just point out that they all have extremely good signage and very full parking lots on Sunday. Whether that's one church or five churches is a seminary debate. Whether people are hearing the gospel is the real question and from what I can tell the answer is yes.
Should Christians pray to saints — or is asking Mary and the dead for help straight-up idolatry?
56 comments
Did Christianity give birth to modern science — or did the church spend centuries trying to strangle it in the cradle?
56 comments
Does God choose who gets saved, or do you choose God — and is Calvinism secretly making God into a monster?
55 comments
Do humans have an immortal soul — or did the church steal that idea from Plato and dress it up as Scripture?
55 comments