Council Bluffs Christian families are sharply divided over whether pulling children into homeschool co-ops is the godly choice or whether staying in local public schools is a Kingdom calling to be salt and light. Where does faithful parenting end and cultural retreat begin?
Join the debate to comment
Reading is free. Members pay to post — that's why it stays clean.
Add your commentI taught fourth grade at Bloomer Elementary for eleven years before retiring and I can tell you with complete confidence that the Christian families who stayed and engaged — who came to conferences, who prayed for us teachers, whose kids were kind and curious — those families had more impact on that school than any amount of withdrawing ever would have. I miss those kids. They mattered.
Born and raised in Council Bluffs, attended Lewis Central all four years, and I turned out just fine spiritually. My kids go there now. The idea that you have to bubble-wrap your children in a homeschool co-op to raise them Christian is honestly a little insulting to those of us who trust God enough to send our kids into the world. Jesus didn't hide in the temple. He walked into the mess.
My grandmother taught Sunday school at First Baptist on 9th Street for 40 years. She used to say 'you can be so heavenly minded you're no earthly good.' I think about that every time I see another family pull their kids out of CBCSD and then wonder why the schools keep getting worse. Who do you think is supposed to be influencing those institutions if not us?
That Puritan argument above is doing a LOT of work and most of it is wrong. Public common schools were explicitly designed to create shared civic identity across denominations — that was the whole point of the Horace Mann movement which Iowa embraced early. They weren't homeschool co-ops. They were a deliberate attempt to build community across difference. Which is actually a pretty Christian impulse if you think about it.
ok so i homeschool my three kids through the Pottawattamie co-op off Missouri Ave and i'm SO tired of being made to feel like i'm abandoning society. we're not hiding. we volunteer at Mercy Housing, we do food pantry at Believer's Fellowship every other saturday, my kids know more about serving their community than half the kids sitting in a classroom being taught that truth is relative. discipleship isn't withdrawal.
i grew up homeschooled here in council bluffs and i have to be honest it really stunted me socially. didnt go to a real classroom until community college and i was totally unprepared. my parents thought they were protecting my faith but mostly they were just protecting me from life. i love my parents and i know they meant well. just sayin there are real costs that dont show up in the theology debate.
Genuine question for the Council Bluffs families in this thread: have any of you actually sat down with your pastor and worked through a theology of education together, with Scripture, before making this choice either direction? Or did you mostly just do what felt right or what your friend group was doing? Because I suspect a lot of this debate is social and economic and only dressed up in theological language after the fact. And that's true on BOTH sides. I've been guilty of it myself.
Fun fact that nobody seems to mention: Iowa actually has some of the loosest homeschool regulations in the entire country. No required testing, no oversight, no curriculum standards. That's a FEATURE to some families and a BUG to others. I personally think accountability structures matter and the complete absence of them isn't automatically 'freedom in Christ.' It's just freedom. Those are different things.
Counterpoint: statistically, homeschooled kids in evangelical bubbles show higher rates of deconstruction in young adulthood because they were never taught to engage real questions. I've seen it at my own church. Five families homeschooled aggressively, and three of those kids are now atheists in their 20s. Correlation isn't causation but it should at least give us pause before we act like homeschooling is automatically the godly path.
Can someone explain to me how letting your 9-year-old 'be salt and light' in a school where the curriculum is actively hostile to Christian anthropology is wise parenting and not just virtue signaling for progressive Christians? I'm serious. My daughter came home from Thomas Jefferson Middle School last year with a worksheet that directly contradicted what we teach at home about human nature. At what age do we expect children to be apologists?
Nope. Hard disagree with the whole premise. The Bible commands parents to raise children in the instruction of the Lord — Deuteronomy 6, Proverbs 22:6, Ephesians 6:4. The public school system in Iowa was literally founded on Christian principles and has since been systematically stripped of them. Sending your children there unequipped is not salt and light, it's negligence dressed up in theological language.
Both sides act like this is a simple question and it drives me crazy. We homeschooled our oldest for three years, then put her back in public school for high school, and we made that decision prayerfully both times. Context changed. She changed. Our church community here at Cornerstone actually supported both decisions which is how it should be. Stop making this a litmus test for real Christianity.
Just moved here from Omaha eight months ago and honestly did not expect Council Bluffs to have such strong feelings about this lol. But for real, I think people are treating this like there's ONE right answer and there isn't. Faithful discipleship looks different for every family. Some are called to stay in public schools, some aren't. Can we stop making each other feel condemned for prayerful decisions?
Actually the Puritans who founded American education ALSO homeschooled and used classical Christian curriculum, so homeschooling is historically the MORE traditional Christian approach and public schooling is the modern innovation. People forget that. The one-room schoolhouses of western Iowa were basically homeschool co-ops with a single teacher. We're just returning to our roots.
Should Christians pray to saints — or is asking Mary and the dead for help straight-up idolatry?
56 comments
Did Christianity give birth to modern science — or did the church spend centuries trying to strangle it in the cradle?
56 comments
Does God choose who gets saved, or do you choose God — and is Calvinism secretly making God into a monster?
55 comments
Do humans have an immortal soul — or did the church steal that idea from Plato and dress it up as Scripture?
55 comments