NYC public schools are among the most academically competitive in the country but also reflect the city's fully secular pluralism. Should Christian parents view enrollment as a mission field and a civic good, or prioritize private Christian education even at enormous financial sacrifice in one of the world's most expensive cities?
Join the debate to comment
Reading is free. Members pay to post — that's why it stays clean.
Add your commentMy grandparents came from Puerto Rico, joined a Pentecostal church in the South Bronx, and sent every one of their eight kids through public schools because that was the only path upward they had. Those kids became nurses, teachers, a pastor, a city councilman. Tell me again about parental negligence. I will wait.
My wife and I agonized over this for two years before our son started kindergarten. We visited public schools, Catholic schools, two Protestant classical schools. We prayed, we read, we argued at 11pm over Francis Schaeffer and Tim Keller. You know what we landed on? Public school, robust church community, dinner table conversations every night, and the full acknowledgment that we might revisit this every single year. There is no perfect answer. Anyone selling you one is selling something.
Born and raised in Flatbush, went through the NYC public school system K-12, and I'm a deacon in my church now. The idea that public school automatically corrupts your kids is honestly insulting to every Christian family that couldn't afford anything else. My parents prayed with me every morning before school, my church community was tight, and here I am. Faithful presence starts at HOME, people.
I actually think this debate reveals more about class anxiety than theology. Middle-class Christian parents in Park Slope and Astoria are terrified of what happens when their kids mix with 'the wrong crowd' and they dress that fear up in Deuteronomy. Meanwhile working-class Christian families in the South Bronx and East New York have been sending their kids to public school forever and nobody writes think pieces about their parental negligence.
can we stop pretending that private Christian school in NYC is even a realistic option for most families lol. St. Ann's in Brooklyn Heights is like $60,000 a year. SIXTY THOUSAND. my husband and i are both working full time and we're already paying $3,400/month in rent in Ridgewood. what exactly are we supposed to sacrifice here, food?
The research actually shows — and I'm a public school teacher at a middle school in Harlem so I've looked into this — that children who leave public school for Christian private school don't actually demonstrate meaningfully stronger faith outcomes in adulthood. The strongest predictor is consistent church attendance and parental modeling. We keep having the wrong debate.
I think Andy Crouch's whole 'faithful presence' framework is being wildly misapplied in this debate. He was talking about cultural institutions and professional life, not about whether your seven-year-old should be a missionary at PS 158. Children are not missionaries. They are children. They need formation before they can do reformation.
Nope. Hard disagree. The curriculum in these schools has shifted so dramatically in the last decade that calling it 'neutral pluralism' is laughable. It's not neutral. It has a worldview, and that worldview is aggressively post-Christian. I pulled my kids out of PS 87 on the Upper West Side three years ago and I have zero regrets.
Okay but here's the thing nobody wants to say — the specialized high schools like Stuyvesant and Bronx Science are genuinely world-class and disproportionately populated by kids from immigrant Christian families, many of them Korean and West African evangelicals. If Christian withdrawal from public school is so spiritually wise, someone explain why the most academically serious Christian parents in Queens are fighting tooth and nail to GET their kids INTO Stuyvesant.
I grew up Catholic on Staten Island and attended Catholic school through 8th grade. By high school I was in a public school and honestly the Catholic school kids were the wildest ones. Just saying. Controlled environments don't produce virtue, they just delay the test.
Question for the people saying Christian school is the only faithful option: which one? Because half the Catholic schools in the Bronx got shut down over the last 15 years. The evangelical options are tiny and waitlisted and some of them have serious issues with accreditation. The 'just choose Christian education' crowd acts like there's some robust infrastructure here waiting for us. There mostly isn't.
Just moved here from Nashville six months ago for work and I have to say this debate hits different when you're actually living it. Back home we had three solid classical Christian schools within 20 minutes. Here I've been on a waitlist at Grace Classical Academy since before my daughter was born. The geography of this city makes every theological conviction more expensive.
With all due respect the Bible clearly commands us to bring up children in the training and instruction of the Lord. Deuteronomy 6 is pretty explicit that education is a 24/7 covenant responsibility. Handing your child to a state institution for 35 hours a week that explicitly excludes God from its frame of reference is not 'faithful presence.' It is abdication. I will defend that position to anyone here.
fun fact: Fiorello La Guardia himself was raised in a multi-faith household and went through NYC public schools and basically ran the greatest city government this town ever saw. not saying that settles a theological debate but maybe public formation produces people who can actually function in a pluralist democracy which, last I checked, is also something Christians are supposed to do
Should Christians pray to saints — or is asking Mary and the dead for help straight-up idolatry?
56 comments
Did Christianity give birth to modern science — or did the church spend centuries trying to strangle it in the cradle?
56 comments
Does God choose who gets saved, or do you choose God — and is Calvinism secretly making God into a monster?
55 comments
Do humans have an immortal soul — or did the church steal that idea from Plato and dress it up as Scripture?
55 comments