With large multisite churches drawing Hudson County believers across the turnpike and through the tunnel, some argue the programs and production value are worth the commute. Others insist faithfulness to a local neighborhood body is a biblical priority megachurches cannot replace.
Join the debate to comment
Reading is free. Members pay to post — that's why it stays clean.
Add your commentI drove 25 minutes to a multisite campus for three years. Volunteer coordinator never learned my name despite me serving on the welcome team. Switched to a congregation of maybe 90 people near the Meadowlands area and within six weeks the pastor had already called me personally when I missed two Sundays in a row. That phone call changed my faith more than any production budget ever could. I'm not saying megachurches are evil, I'm saying proximity and accountability are not incidental to discipleship — they ARE discipleship. Anyone in Hudson County who wants to push back on that, I'd genuinely love the conversation.
Born and raised in Secaucus, attended First Baptist on County Ave my entire childhood. My parents walked there. Now I watch my neighbors load their minivans every Sunday to drive to that massive campus in Paramus or wherever and I just... I don't get it. The New Testament church met in HOUSES. Houses, people. Not in buildings with Jumbotrons and parking garages. There is something deeply convicting about the fact that the early believers were embedded in their actual neighborhoods and knew each other's suffering firsthand. Your megachurch pastor does not know your name. I promise you he does not.
Lol at this debate happening in SECAUCUS of all places. We have a ShopRite, a movie theater, and existential questions about ecclesiology. Love this town.
Moved here from Nashville eight months ago and I'll say this: the smaller congregations in Hudson County have a warmth I haven't found at the big multisite I've been visiting. People actually waited after service to help me find a dentist and a decent mechanic. That's the body of Christ functioning. The big campus I tried first had better coffee and worse community. Make of that what you will.
Someone needs to correct the comment above me — ekklesia just means an assembly of called-out people, it carries no inherent size requirement whatsoever. The word was used for civic gatherings of hundreds in the Greek world. You cannot use etymology to legislate church size, that's not how biblical interpretation works. Read Fee and Stuart.
ok but can we be honest for a second — the kids programs at some of these larger churches are genuinely incredible and as a single mom trying to raise two boys in faith that matters to me. my neighborhood church had like 4 kids total in sunday school. my sons are actually excited to go now. isnt that worth something scripturally
The biblical case is actually pretty clear cut — Acts 2:46 says they met daily from HOUSE TO HOUSE. That Greek word for church, ekklesia, literally means 'called out assembly' which the original apostles intended to be small and localized. Megachurches actually violate the etymology of the word church itself when you think about it.
hard disagree with the whole framing here. God calls people to specific congregations not specific ZIP codes. end of discussion
Should Christians pray to saints — or is asking Mary and the dead for help straight-up idolatry?
56 comments
Did Christianity give birth to modern science — or did the church spend centuries trying to strangle it in the cradle?
56 comments
Does God choose who gets saved, or do you choose God — and is Calvinism secretly making God into a monster?
55 comments
Do humans have an immortal soul — or did the church steal that idea from Plato and dress it up as Scripture?
55 comments