With massive multisite churches drawing thousands across the boroughs and tiny storefront congregations fighting to keep the lights on, locals are split: does the Holy Spirit move more powerfully in an arena-style worship experience or in a 60-person church where everyone knows your name?
Join the debate to comment
Reading is free. Members pay to post — that's why it stays clean.
Add your commentMy uncle actually founded a storefront church on Jerome Avenue back in 1987. That man mortgaged his own apartment TWICE to keep it open during the crack epidemic and ministered to people nobody else would touch. The neighborhood around that church is completely transformed. No megachurch bought those blocks back. Faithful small congregations did. Remember that.
My genuine answer after 15 years in ministry here: go where you will actually show up consistently. The best church for you is the one you will actually attend, serve in, give to, and let people speak truth into your life. An imperfect small church you're committed to beats a spectacular megachurch you attend twice a year at Christmas and Easter every single time. Attendance is not discipleship.
Grew up in a storefront Pentecostal church on Flatbush Avenue. My grandmother knew every single person in that congregation by name, prayed for them by name, visited them in the hospital by name. Tell me a megachurch with a fog machine and a light show is replacing THAT. I'll wait.
Someone needs to say this: the small congregation vs megachurch debate is partly a class and culture conversation that NYC Christians dont want to have. Whose aesthetics get centered? Whose worship style is treated as default? Ask the Caribbean and West African congregations keeping three-hour services alive in Queens and Brooklyn what they think about production value being equated with spiritual health.
The theological depth at most megachurches is approximately three inches. Great lighting. Excellent parking validation. Roughly the same scriptural content as a motivational poster. But hey, at least the app works.
Okay but can we also be honest that some of these neighborhood churches have the same 11 people who've attended since 1974 and have zero interest in welcoming anybody new? Commitment to a small church is beautiful. Insularity disguised as intimacy is not the same thing.
I want to push back on something here because I think we're creating a false binary. I attend a multisite church with campuses in Harlem and the Bronx and our community groups meet in apartments with like 8 to 12 people every single week. The large gathering and the small intimate community are not enemies. They're actually designed to work together. Read Acts 2 again — temple courts AND house to house.
Hard disagree with the premise of this whole debate. The Holy Spirit doesnt check the square footage before showing up. Ive had genuine encounters with God at Brooklyn Tabernacle and also at my cousins tiny AME church in the Bronx with maybe 40 people and a keyboard that was slightly out of tune the whole service. Stop gatekeeping revival.
Nope. Hard disagree. When your church has a green room and a hospitality rider for the guest speaker, you've built a brand, not a Body.
Born in Staten Island, lived in Manhattan for 22 years now. The megachurch experience always felt to me like showing up to a dinner party where the host has no idea who you are. Beautiful food, great music playing, but you go home the same as you came. I think Jesus was more of a dinner-table guy than a stadium guy if im being honest about it.
just moved to queens from ohio six months ago and honestly the small congregation i found in jackson heights saved me. i knew literally nobody in this city. the pastor remembered my coffee order when we did fellowship hour. a campus that seats 4,000 people was never going to do that for me
Fun fact: Charles Spurgeon's Metropolitan Tabernacle in London held over 5,000 people in the 1800s. So the idea that large congregations are somehow a modern compromise or a capitalist invention is just historically illiterate. Spurgeon wasn't selling concert tickets.
i literally cannot afford to tithe at a church that has a full time social media director sorry not sorry
Should Christians pray to saints — or is asking Mary and the dead for help straight-up idolatry?
56 comments
Did Christianity give birth to modern science — or did the church spend centuries trying to strangle it in the cradle?
56 comments
Does God choose who gets saved, or do you choose God — and is Calvinism secretly making God into a monster?
55 comments
Do humans have an immortal soul — or did the church steal that idea from Plato and dress it up as Scripture?
55 comments