NYC believers earning modest wages face housing costs that would stagger most of the country, making a strict tithe feel financially crushing. Should pastors preach the tithe as an unwavering biblical standard, or is faithful generosity better measured by sacrifice relative to local economic reality?
Join the debate to comment
Reading is free. Members pay to post — that's why it stays clean.
Add your commentFun fact for the thread: the OT tithe was actually THREE tithes — the Levitical tithe, the festival tithe, and the poor tithe — which together totaled closer to 23% every three years. So the people screaming about 10% being the sacred non-negotiable standard don't even have the history right. The NT doesn't reinstate the tithe at all. Paul says give what you've purposed in your heart, cheerfully, not grudgingly. That's the actual command we're under. This isn't liberalism, it's just reading the whole Bible.
My wife and I pastor a small church in Crown Heights. I'll be honest — we stopped preaching a hard 10% figure about four years ago and switched to preaching first-fruits generosity and proportional sacrifice. Giving in our congregation went UP. Not down. UP. Because people stopped white-knuckling a number out of fear and started genuinely praying about what sacrifice looked like for their household. I'm not saying that's the answer for every church but I am saying the fear-based tithe message was killing our people quietly.
Born and raised in the Bronx, attending the same Pentecostal church my grandmother helped found in 1971. I love my pastor dearly but when he preaches tithing like we're all living in suburban Ohio I want to stand up and say SIR. My net take-home is $3,100 a month. My rent in Fordham is $1,750. You do that math and then tell me God is going to curse me for giving 7% instead of 10. The widow's mite wasn't about a percentage — it was about the posture of the heart. I've believed that my whole life and I'm not ashamed of it.
I moved here from Nashville two years ago for work and the culture shock around money in these churches is REAL. Back home my pastor would preach tithing and it felt challenging but doable. Up here I joined a congregation in Astoria and the pastor — wonderful man, truly — gave the same sermon almost word for word. But a family of four sitting near me told me after service they were already choosing between tithing and keeping their MetroCards loaded to get to work. That broke something in me. Context is not an excuse for disobedience but it absolutely has to inform how we apply Scripture pastorally.
okay genuine question for the people defending strict 10%: are you tithing on gross or net? because I've literally been in three different NYC churches and gotten three totally different answers from three different associate pastors. If the rule is supposedly non-negotiable you'd think the rulebook would be a little clearer lol
Respectfully, I think we need to separate two questions that keep getting tangled here. Question one: Is the tithe a binding command for NT believers? Legitimate theological debate, reasonable people disagree. Question two: Should a pastor in NYC preach it without any acknowledgment of local economic conditions? That one seems obvious to me — no, of course not. Pastoral wisdom means you know your congregation. The same text preached to the same people in the same moment should still account for whether those people are one missed paycheck from losing their apartment. That's not compromising Scripture. That's actually doing the hard work of applying it faithfully. Anyone who says otherwise has probably never had to choose between their electric bill and their tithe envelope.
this whole debate frustrates me bc no one ever asks where the tithe money actually GOES. i grew up in a megachurch in midtown and watched leadership build a multi-million dollar facility while members of the congregation were food insecure. maybe fix that before demanding 10% from a home health aide making 32k a year in queens
Hard disagree with the whole framing of this question. The tithe is in Malachi 3:10. "Bring the whole tithe into the storehouse." Not "bring what's convenient after your landlord takes his cut." God didn't put an asterisk next to that verse that says *unless you live in a high cost of living metro area. If anything living somewhere expensive is a spiritual opportunity to trust Him more radically. I know that sounds harsh but coddling people into comfortable giving isn't pastoral care, it's spiritual negligence.
Should Christians pray to saints — or is asking Mary and the dead for help straight-up idolatry?
56 comments
Did Christianity give birth to modern science — or did the church spend centuries trying to strangle it in the cradle?
56 comments
Does God choose who gets saved, or do you choose God — and is Calvinism secretly making God into a monster?
55 comments
Do humans have an immortal soul — or did the church steal that idea from Plato and dress it up as Scripture?
55 comments