Should Saginaw-area churches redirect a bigger slice of their budgets to local food pantries and rent assistance rather than international missions?

• YB

  Yuki B.3d ago

  Born and raised in Saginaw, went to school right off Blue Mound Road, and I can tell you firsthand — the need here is REAL. We had a family in our congregation last winter who couldn't make rent after the husband got laid off at the plant. The benevolence fund was basically tapped out by February. Meanwhile we're sending $40,000 a year to a mission partner in Southeast Asia. I love those people, I truly do, but something feels upside down when your neighbor is choosing between lights and groceries.

  143Reply
• H

  Hana3d ago

  This debate comes up every budget season at our church and honestly I'm exhausted by it. Both sides act like the other side wants people to suffer. Nobody wants that. Can we please just acknowledge that a church doing $2 million in annual giving can probably afford to beef up the local pantry fund AND keep missionaries on the field without turning it into a theological cage match every single October?

  112Reply
• J

  Jordan3d ago

  ok genuine question for the 'missions first' crowd — how many of yall have actually been to the Saginaw food pantry on White Settlement Rd recently? because I volunteer there twice a month and the line wraps around the building on Tuesdays. These aren't lazy people. These are working families. Truck drivers, warehouse workers, single moms doing two jobs. Tell me again how it's more righteous to fund a conference in another country than to feed people ten minutes from your church building.

  98Reply
• T

  Taylor2d ago

  I appreciate the passion here but I want to gently push back on the idea that international missions funding is just money disappearing into a void. Most of those dollars go to church planting in areas with literally zero gospel witness. Zero. When a church is planted in a remote region it creates a LOCAL solution to LOCAL poverty because the church becomes the community anchor. So in a weird way, international missions IS local benevolence — just for a different local. Ours just happens to already have seventeen churches on the same street.

  88Reply
• FT

  Feli T.3d ago

  Hard disagree. The Great Commission doesn't come with an asterisk that says 'unless your zip code needs help.' Matthew 28 is not a suggestion and it's not geographically limited. If we gut international missions every time the local economy hiccups we'll never finish the task. God will provide for Saginaw. Who's providing for unreached villages in Ethiopia or Papua New Guinea? Us. That's who.

  67Reply
• TL

  Theo L.3d ago

  Fun fact that nobody seems to know: Saginaw ISD actually reported a significant jump in students qualifying for free and reduced lunch over the last couple years. So the need is measurably growing right here in our own school district. Our churches should be embarrassed if we can't respond to data that's literally public record. I'll take the downvotes but somebody had to say it.

  54Reply
• T

  Taylor3d ago

  Moved here from Fort Worth about three years ago and got plugged into a church off Saginaw Blvd. What surprised me honestly was how little the local benevolence budget was compared to the missions line item. Not criticizing — I get the theology — but it was a culture shock. Back at my old church we had a dedicated deacon team just for local rent assistance. Seemed to work fine AND they still supported overseas missionaries. Maybe the answer is just better stewardship and fundraising, not an either/or.

  41Reply
• A

  Alex3d ago

  Theologically speaking, the early church in Acts 2 and Acts 4 prioritized meeting the needs of those within the local body first, THEN expanded outward. It wasn't either/or, it was concentric circles — Jerusalem first, then Judea, then the uttermost parts. A lot of evangelical churches have flipped that model on its head for complicated historical reasons tied to the 19th century missions movement. Worth studying before you quote the Great Commission like it settles everything.

  29Reply
• OL

  Omar L.3d ago

  the bible literally says if anyone does not provide for his own household he has denied the faith and is worse than an unbeliever. 1 timothy 5:8. that principle scales up. your church is your household. your community is your household. start there. the international missionaries arent going anywhere.

  17Reply

More debates people can't stop arguing about