Many Christian families in the city feel SFUSD's values conflict sharply with their faith, while others argue faithful kids can be salt and light inside public schools. Where does the line between protection and witness fall?
Join the debate to comment
Reading is free. Members pay to post — that's why it stays clean.
Add your commentHot take incoming: homeschooling in San Francisco specifically is a massive privilege that people love to frame as a moral duty. Do you know what it costs to have one parent home full time in this city?? The median rent here. Do the math. Working-class Christian families in Bayview and Excelsior don't have the luxury of this theological debate. They're sending their kids to SFUSD because the alternative is the kids eat less. Can we stop pretending this is a universal Christian obligation?
Born and raised in the Sunset District, attended public schools K-12, and I turned out just fine as a Christian, thank you very much. My parents talked to me every single night about what I learned and whether it lined up with Scripture. THAT'S the parenting. You can't just outsource your child's entire moral formation to whatever institution they attend and then panic when the institution isn't a church. The real question isn't about SFUSD — it's about whether Christian parents are actually doing the work at home.
I actually think the commenter above has the history completely backwards — for most of Christian history, educated children attended schools run by the church OR the state, and parents were not the primary academic instructors. Medieval cathedral schools, anyone? This idea that homeschooling is somehow the 'biblical' model is a very recent American evangelical talking point, not an ancient Christian tradition. Downvote me if you want, but please read some church history first.
Salt and light, people. SALT AND LIGHT. Jesus did not say 'go ye therefore into a Christian bubble and insulate thyself from the world.' He walked straight into the messiest, most spiritually complicated places imaginable. If we genuinely believe our kids' faith is so fragile that a public school in the Richmond District will shatter it, maybe we need to examine what kind of faith we've actually built in them.
My kids go to a public school off 19th Avenue. Their best friend is the kid who asks the hardest questions about faith because HE doesn't share it. My 11 year old has had to actually think about what she believes and articulate it. I watch her grow spiritually in ways I don't think she would in an environment where everyone already agrees. I'm not saying this is right for every family. I'm just saying the struggle isn't always the enemy.
Deuteronomy 6:7 says to teach your children diligently 'when you sit in your house, when you walk by the way, when you lie down, and when you rise up.' Biblically speaking, the PRIMARY responsibility for a child's education was NEVER meant to be delegated to the state. The public school system as we know it has only existed for like 150 years. Christians need to stop acting like sending kids to government schools is the historical default and homeschooling is the radical option. It's literally the opposite.
we pulled our daughter out of her Noe Valley elementary two years ago and i will never regret it. not even a little bit. the things she was coming home confused about in SECOND GRADE were things i wasnt even ready to explain yet as her parent. i should get to decide when and how those conversations happen. thats not fear, thats stewardship.
Moved here from Fresno three years ago for work and I'll be honest, the culture shock at the school level was real. Attended an SFUSD open house and left with my jaw on the floor. Enrolled my son at a Christian school in the Mission instead. Zero regrets. I respect people who make different choices but for our family, the foundation years matter too much to experiment with.
can someone tell me why this is even a debate lol. private school, homeschool, public school — none of those options automatically makes you a good Christian parent or a bad one. ive seen kids from Christian schools who cant find a Bible verse to save their lives and ive seen public school kids who lead youth group better than the adults. the school isnt the point.
Should Christians pray to saints — or is asking Mary and the dead for help straight-up idolatry?
56 comments
Did Christianity give birth to modern science — or did the church spend centuries trying to strangle it in the cradle?
56 comments
Does God choose who gets saved, or do you choose God — and is Calvinism secretly making God into a monster?
55 comments
Do humans have an immortal soul — or did the church steal that idea from Plato and dress it up as Scripture?
55 comments