Has Vacation Bible School in San Jose become a members-only summer activity instead of the neighborhood outreach it was designed to be?

• J

  Jamie2d ago

  VBS was literally invented by D.L. Moody's movement in the late 1800s specifically to reach street kids in cities. STREET KIDS. Kids whose parents weren't in church. The whole DNA of the program is neighborhood evangelism. If your VBS is just a fun week for kids who already know John 3:16, you've turned a net into a fishbowl. I say this with love but somebody had to say it.

  178Reply
• E

  Elena2d ago

  Born and raised in Willow Glen, went to VBS at my church every single summer from 1987 to 1994. Back then half the neighborhood kids showed up because my mom literally walked door to door with flyers. Nobody thought it was weird. Nobody felt harassed. They came, they made crafts, they heard about Jesus, and some of them are still believers today. We gave that up somewhere along the line and replaced it with slick online registration portals that only church families know how to find. We did it to ourselves.

  143Reply
• R

  Riley2d ago

  I coordinate children's ministry at a church off Story Road and I want to push back on something: our registration isn't "members only" by design, but it FUNCTIONALLY becomes that because we advertise almost entirely through our own app, our own email list, and our own Sunday bulletin. Of course only our people sign up. We haven't actually invited anyone else. That's not a VBS problem, that's a marketing problem and honestly a faith problem. We're afraid of rejection so we don't ask.

  97Reply
• JR

  Jamie R.2d ago

  Okay but door-knocking in Berryessa or Evergreen is NOT the same as Willow Glen in 1989. My neighborhood is like 60% recent immigrants from Vietnam and India. Showing up unannounced at someone's door asking about Jesus is going to get you a politely closed door at best and a Nextdoor post about "solicitors" at worst. The cultural context has completely changed. That doesn't mean we abandon outreach, it means we get smarter about it.

  89Reply
• ML

  Maya L.2d ago

  We tried partnering with the Roosevelt Community Center two summers ago to host a joint event, kind of a VBS lite situation open to everyone in the neighborhood. Got maybe 35 kids who had zero church connection. Some parents stayed and asked questions. One family started attending. Just one, but that's one family that wasn't there before. It took way more work than a normal VBS week but it felt like what Jesus actually called us to do. Worth it.

  61Reply
• H

  Hana2d ago

  just moved here from Tulsa six months ago and I cannot get over how different it is. Back home our VBS had 400 kids every year, half from unchurched families, because church is just part of the community fabric there. Here I mention VBS at work and people look at me like I said I'm taking my kid to a Renaissance fair. The secular tech culture is THICK. Churches need to lead with the fun, the community, the free childcare honestly, and let the Gospel speak through relationship over time. Bait and switch? No. Patience? Yes.

  53Reply
• D

  Diego2d ago

  The real issue nobody wants to say out loud is liability. Once you open registration to the general public you need background checks, proper ratios, release forms, the whole thing. Small churches especially just dont have the volunteer bandwidth to do all that AND run a quality program. So they quietly cap it at families they already know. I'm not saying thats RIGHT but pretending it's purely a lack of evangelistic vision is naive. There are real logistical reasons this happens.

  34Reply
• AR

  Alex R.2d ago

  nope. hard disagree with the whole framing here. VBS was ALWAYS partly for church kids too. sunday school teachers need somewhere to plug kids in during summer. it serves both purposes and acting like it's failed because the pews kids show up is just moving the goalposts.

  22Reply
• T2

  Taylor 212d ago

  Fun fact: VBS actually stands for Vacation Bible School, not Vacation Bible Session or Vacation Bible Series — I know churches keep rebranding it but the "School" part matters because it signals learning and open enrollment, not membership. ... Okay I realize that's kind of a minor point but I do think the language we use shapes the culture we build. Call it a community event. Put it on Eventbrite. List it in the city parks and rec newsletter. San Jose Parks actually lets nonprofits post free events. Has anyone actually tried that?

  19Reply

More debates people can't stop arguing about